Past Auction

54 Oneill Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Last Updated: February 17, 2025

54 Oneill Ave, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

EMV$ 855,700

Past Auction

APR 3, 2023

Single Family Home

Town House

Estimated Market ValueEMV

$855,700

54 Oneill Ave

    
bool(false)

bool(true)

bool(true)

int(0)

Estimated Market ValueEMV

$855,700

Bay Shore, NY 11706

—

Suffolk County

Favorite

Calculate Flipping Profit

Case Number

608508/2023

Recording Date

Apr 3, 2023 (748 days ago)

Latest Document Date

Feb 17, 2025 (62 days ago)

Judgment Amount

12,345,678.90

Original Loan Amount

12,345,678.90

Summarized Complaint

The text you see blurred has been intentionally replaced to notify you that access to this content requires an active subscription and sufficient REbbons View Credits (RVC). To unlock and view the full information, please ensure you have purchased the necessary tokens and are subscribed to the relevant region. Your subscription and credits will grant you complete access.

This blurred content is a placeholder. To view the full information, you need an active subscription and sufficient RVC tokens. .

Data marked with is not visible to unregistered users

Key Documents of the Case 3

NOTICE John Doe

Dec 24, 2024

NOTICE Jane Q. Public

Jun 25, 2024

SUMMONS Jane Grey

Apr 3, 2023

Property Address (By court documents) 1

1.	54 Oneill Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Suffolk County, NY
Legal Description of Property District 0500 Section 341.00 Block 000 Lot 000 Parcel ID / Tax Map # / APN 0500-341.00-000-000 The parcel located at the specified block and lot within Suffolk County, as detailed in the plat officially filed with the County Recorder.

Parties 2

Plaintiffs / Petitioners
1.	John Unknown Attorney Represented

Defendants / Respondents
1.	Jane Quintessential Attorney Represented

Legal Representatives 2

	Attorney Name	Client Name
1.	Baby Doe John Noone	CLIENT NAME Plaintiff, Since Apr 3, 2023
Attorney Name Baby Doe Company Name John Noone Office Address NEW YORK, NY 10004 Phone Number 012-345-6789 Registration Number 0123456789
2.	Jane Archetypal John Shadow	CLIENT NAME Plaintiff, Since Sep 28, 2023
Attorney Name Jane Archetypal Company Name John Shadow Office Address NEW YORK, NY 10004 Phone Number 012-345-6789 Registration Number 0123456789

Show more Hide

Property details for 54 Oneill Ave

Status

Off Market

Type

Single Family Home

Town House

Year Built

1907

Flood Factor

6 / 10

Last Sold

$20K in 2022

The description and property data below may have been provided by a third party, the homeowner or public records.

54 Oneill Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 is a Single Family Home built in 1907. This property was last sold for $20,000 in 2022 and currently has an estimated value of $855,700. According to the Bay Shore public records, the property at 54 Oneill Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 has approximately 2,684 square feet, with a lot size of 11,761 square feet. Nearby schools include Brook Avenue Elementary School, South Country School and Fifth Avenue School.

Property facts

Property features

Listing information

Year Built:
Year Built:
1907
1907

Location

Zoning:
Zoning:
B
B

Lot size and SQFT

Living Area:
Living Area:
2684
2684

Property Price History

for 54 Oneill Ave

Date	Event	Price	Price/Sqft	Source
Dec 15, 2020	Listing removed	$89,000	$56	OneKeyMLS
Dec 15, 2020	Listing removed	$125,000	$78	OneKeyMLS
Dec 15, 2020	Listing removed	$469,000	$239	OneKeyMLS
Dec 15, 2020	Listing removed	$139,000	$87	OneKeyMLS
Oct 5, 2018	Sold	$463,000	$173	Public Record
Jul 30, 2017	Listing removed	$469,000	$239	OneKeyMLS
Jul 30, 2017	Listing removed	$469,000	$239	MyStateMLS
Mar 30, 2017	Price Changed	$469,000	$239	OneKeyMLS
Sep 12, 2016	Price Changed	$469,000	$239	MyStateMLS
Aug 3, 2016	Sold	$90,000	$34	Public Record
Jul 20, 2016	Listed	$359,000	$183	MyStateMLS
Jul 20, 2016	Listed	$359,000	$183	OneKeyMLS
Dec 11, 2015	Listing removed	$139,000	$87	OneKeyMLS
Jun 16, 2015	Listing removed	$89,000	$56	OneKeyMLS
Dec 1, 2014	Price Changed	$139,000	$87	OneKeyMLS
Apr 27, 2014	Listed	$149,000	$93	OneKeyMLS
Dec 10, 2013	Listed	$89,000	$56	OneKeyMLS
Jul 12, 2012	Listing removed	$179,990	—	OneKeyMLS
Jul 5, 2012	Relisted	$179,990	—	OneKeyMLS
Jul 4, 2012	Listing removed	$179,990	—	OneKeyMLS
Oct 19, 2011	Listed	$179,990	—	OneKeyMLS
Oct 11, 2011	Listing removed	$125,000	$78	OneKeyMLS
Aug 3, 2010	Price Changed	$125,000	$78	OneKeyMLS
Jun 16, 2010	Listed	$150,000	$94	OneKeyMLS
Dec 5, 2006	Sold	$330,000	$123	Public Record
Dec 5, 1988	Sold	$105,000	$39	Public Record
Sep 29, 1988	Sold	$43,000	$16	Public Record

Show more Hide

Property Tax History

for 54 Oneill Ave

Year	Taxes	Land	Additions	Total Assessment
2023	$12,862	$7,300	$33,200	$40,500
2017	$9,480	$7,300	$25,200	$32,500
2016	$9,457	$7,300	$25,200	$32,500
2015	$9,464	$7,300	$25,200	$32,500
2014	$9,432	$7,300	$25,200	$32,500
2013	$9,218	$7,300	$25,200	$32,500
2012	$8,894	$7,300	$25,200	$32,500
2011	$8,565	$7,300	$25,200	$32,500
2010	$8,389	$7,300	$25,200	$32,500
2008	$8,022	$7,300	$25,200	$32,500

Show more Hide

Sold Homes

near 54 Oneill Ave

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
1327 Elayne Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$720,000 12/30/2024	1955	5	4	2,808 +124difference	12,197	0.50 mi
1327 Elayne AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1955 Built 2,808 +124 Sqft 12,197 Lot Size 0.50 mi Distance
8 Maddox Ave Islip, NY 11751SF	$612,000 12/02/2024	1969	4	2	2,100 -584	10,019	0.98 mi
8 Maddox AveSF Islip, NY 11751 1969 Built 2,100 -584 Sqft 10,019 Lot Size 0.98 mi Distance
30 Redmond Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$545,000 04/11/2025	1915	3	3	1,728 -956	10,019	0.15 mi
30 Redmond AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1915 Built 1,728 -956 Sqft 10,019 Lot Size 0.15 mi Distance
231 Montana Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$640,000 04/04/2025	1976	4	2	1,676 -1,008	11,326	0.90 mi
231 Montana AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1976 Built 1,676 -1,008 Sqft 11,326 Lot Size 0.90 mi Distance
23 Benjamin St Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$670,000 11/08/2024	2024	3	3	1,600 -1,084	5,227	0.79 mi
23 Benjamin StSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 2024 Built 1,600 -1,084 Sqft 5,227 Lot Size 0.79 mi Distance
74 Belford Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$580,000 03/25/2025	1954	4	2	6,098 +3,414	6,098	0.12 mi
74 Belford AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1954 Built 6,098 +3,414 Sqft 6,098 Lot Size 0.12 mi Distance
9 Harrison Pl Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$325,000 12/24/2024	1900	2	1	626 -2,058	6,970	0.24 mi
9 Harrison PlSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1900 Built 626 -2,058 Sqft 6,970 Lot Size 0.24 mi Distance
71 Redington St Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$401,000 02/21/2025	1935	2	1	652 -2,032	—	0.27 mi
71 Redington StSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1935 Built 652 -2,032 Sqft — Lot Size 0.27 mi Distance
1332 Illinois Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$665,000 10/28/2024	1960	4	3	1,473 -1,211	7,841	0.54 mi
1332 Illinois AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1960 Built 1,473 -1,211 Sqft 7,841 Lot Size 0.54 mi Distance
46 Idaho Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$613,000 01/14/2025	1960	4	2	1,574 -1,110	7,405	0.58 mi
46 Idaho AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1960 Built 1,574 -1,110 Sqft 7,405 Lot Size 0.58 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Homes For Sale

near 54 Oneill Ave

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
225 Pleasant Dr Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$725,000 94 days ago	2001	4	3	2,664 -20difference	6,970	1.89 mi
225 Pleasant DrSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 2001 Built 2,664 -20 Sqft 6,970 Lot Size 1.89 mi Distance
270 Brookville Ave Islip, NY 11751SF	$899,000 122 days ago	1972	6	3	2,729 +45	22,651	1.83 mi
270 Brookville AveSF Islip, NY 11751 1972 Built 2,729 +45 Sqft 22,651 Lot Size 1.83 mi Distance
24 40th St Islip, NY 11751SF	$750,000 57 days ago	1964	5	2	2,572 -112	10,890	1.71 mi
24 40th StSF Islip, NY 11751 1964 Built 2,572 -112 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 1.71 mi Distance
1375 Pine Dr Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$749,000 60 days ago	1952	4	3	2,800 +116	9,583	1.74 mi
1375 Pine DrSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1952 Built 2,800 +116 Sqft 9,583 Lot Size 1.74 mi Distance
77 Church Ave Islip, NY 11751SF	$899,000 63 days ago	1917	4	3	2,518 -166	9,540	1.53 mi
77 Church AveSF Islip, NY 11751 1917 Built 2,518 -166 Sqft 9,540 Lot Size 1.53 mi Distance
326 Brook Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$749,000 95 days ago	1993	5	3	2,500 -184	7,405	0.44 mi
326 Brook AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1993 Built 2,500 -184 Sqft 7,405 Lot Size 0.44 mi Distance
32 Cedar Avenue Ext Islip, NY 11751SF	$1,150,000 74 days ago	1928	4	3	2,875 +191	37,026	1.88 mi
32 Cedar Avenue ExtSF Islip, NY 11751 1928 Built 2,875 +191 Sqft 37,026 Lot Size 1.88 mi Distance
91 Union Ave Islip, NY 11751SF	$729,999 33 days ago	1870	4	2	2,481 -203	9,148	1.70 mi
91 Union AveSF Islip, NY 11751 1870 Built 2,481 -203 Sqft 9,148 Lot Size 1.70 mi Distance
25 Angela Ln Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$999,990 80 days ago	1971	4	3	2,434 -250	23,522	1.04 mi
25 Angela LnSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1971 Built 2,434 -250 Sqft 23,522 Lot Size 1.04 mi Distance
1432A E Forks Rd Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$699,999 134 days ago	1998	4	3	2,424 -260	31,363	0.91 mi
1432A E Forks RdSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1998 Built 2,424 -260 Sqft 31,363 Lot Size 0.91 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Home Value

for 54 Oneill Ave

Estimated values are not a substitute for professional expertise. Contact your RE agent for a market assessment.

Schools

serving 54 Oneill Ave

School Name	Rating	Grades	Distance
Brook Avenue Elementary School 45 Brook Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706	—	K−2	0.11 mi
K−2 Grades Parent Rating 0.11 mi Distance
South Country School 885 Hampshire Road, Bay Shore, NY 11706	3 / 10	3−5	2.34 mi
3−5 Grades Parent Rating 2.34 mi Distance
Fifth Avenue School 217 5th Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706	—	K−2	0.88 mi
K−2 Grades Parent Rating 0.88 mi Distance
Bay Shore Middle School 393 Brook Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706	5 / 10	6−8	0.74 mi
6−8 Grades Parent Rating 0.74 mi Distance
Bay Shore Senior High School 155 Third Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706	5 / 10	9−12	0.54 mi
9−12 Grades Parent Rating 0.54 mi Distance
St Patrick School MONTAUK HWY, Bay Shore, NY 11706	—	PK−8	1.39 mi
PK−8 Grades Parent Rating 1.39 mi Distance

Show more Hide

School service boundaries are intended to be used as reference only. To verify enrollment eligibility for a property, contact the school directly.

Flood Factor

for 54 Oneill Ave

6 ^|10

Major

FEMA Zone (Est.)

X (unshaded)

Flood insurance:

Recommended

Flood risks are increasing as sea levels rise and weather patterns change.

This property has a Major Flood Factor .

Flood Factor data provided by FloodFactor.