What is 217-219 Fisher Ave?

217-219 Fisher Ave is a 2,998 square foot house on a 6,849 square foot lot with 6 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. 217-219 Fisher Ave is a house currently priced at $949,999.

What is the price per square foot?

The price per square foot at 217-219 Fisher Ave is $317.

What type of home is 217-219 Fisher Ave?

217-219 Fisher Ave is classified as a multi-family home.

Who is the listing agent or seller?

The listing is provided by Robert DeFalco Realty, Inc..

What is the MLS number for this property?

This property is listed on the MLS with ID 2503726 from StatenIsland.

What is the lot size of this property?

The property sits on a 6,849 square foot lot.

How many photos are available for this home?

DistressedRealEstate.net has 35 photos of 217-219 Fisher Ave.

How much is this home worth?

Based on DistressedRealEstate.net's Staten Island, NY data, we estimate the home's value is $1,189,500.

How long has this home been listed on DistressedRealEstate.net?

217-219 Fisher Ave has been listed on DistressedRealEstate.net since June 26, 2025.

When was this home built?

217-219 Fisher Ave was built in 1915.

When was this home last sold?

217-219 Fisher Ave was last sold in June 20, 2001.

How competitive is the market for this home?

Based on DistressedRealEstate.net's market data, we calculate that market competition in 10307, this home's neighborhood, is somewhat competitive. This home is priced approximately 20% below the estimated market value.

What’s the full address of this home?

The full address for this home is 217-219 Fisher Ave, Staten Island, NY 10307.

217-219 Fisher Ave, Staten Island, NY 10307

Hot Deal

Last Updated: July 10, 2025

217-219 Fisher Ave, Staten Island, NY, 10307

Asking price$ 949,999

Hot Deal

JUN 26, 2025

Multi Family Home

Asking price

$949,999

House View

Incomplete

217-219 Fisher Ave

    
bool(false)

bool(true)

bool(true)

int(0)

Asking price

$949,999

Staten Island, NY 10307

—

Richmond County

Favorite

Calculate Flipping Profit

Please note!

The Hot Deal section reflects only properties processed within the last 20 days and it is renewing on a daily basis.
If you liked a property, you need to add it into your favorites list to be able to see it after the allotted time period.

Property details for 217-219 Fisher Ave

Sells for

80%

of EARV

Status

For Sale

Days on market

17 days

Type

Multi Family Home

Year Built

1915

Stories

Flood Factor

1 / 10

Last Sold

$244K in 2001

The description and property data below may have been provided by a third party, the homeowner or public records.

This is the one! 3 units located on 1 tax lot. 219 fisher is comprised of a 2 family dwelling. 1st floor renovated 2 bedroom paying 2750. 2nd floor 2 bedroom paying 2050. Heat is gas paid by landlord. Electric & cooking gas paid by tenants. 217 Fisher is a completely separated 2-story 2-bed 1.5-bath home. Currently rented under market value at 1590. Equipped with a separate heating system & water heater. All utilities here are paid by the tenant. There is room for rental increase. Located a block from the train station in 1 direction and a block from bus service in another having a car here isnt necessary. All long term tenants with no issues. All tenants are cooperative and keep their apartments in excellent condition. This investment is a no brainer!

Property features

Bedrooms

Bedrooms:
Bedrooms:
6
6

Garage and Parking

Parking Features:
Parking Features:
On Street
On Street

Bathrooms

Full Bathrooms:
Full Bathrooms:
3
3
Total Bathrooms:
Total Bathrooms:
3
3

Homeowners Association

Association:
Association:
No
No
Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees:
Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees:
0
0

Utilities

Electric:
Electric:
220 Volts
220 Volts
Sewer:
Sewer:
City
City

Heating and Cooling

Cooling Features:
Cooling Features:
Units
Units
Heating Features:
Heating Features:
Steam, Natural Gas
Steam, Natural Gas
Heating:
Heating:
Yes
Yes

Land Info

Lot Size Acres:
Lot Size Acres:
0.1572314
0.1572314
Lot Size Dimensions:
Lot Size Dimensions:
50 X 137
50 X 137
Lot Size Square Feet:
Lot Size Square Feet:
6849
6849

Multi-Unit Info

Bedrooms in Unit-1:
Bedrooms in Unit-1:
2
2
Bedrooms in Unit-2:
Bedrooms in Unit-2:
2
2
Bedrooms in Unit-3:
Bedrooms in Unit-3:
2
2
Number of Units:
Number of Units:
5
5
Total Rooms in Unit-1:
Total Rooms in Unit-1:
5
5
Total Rooms in Unit-2:
Total Rooms in Unit-2:
5
5
Total Rooms in Unit-3:
Total Rooms in Unit-3:
5
5
Unit 1 Total Actual Rent:
Unit 1 Total Actual Rent:
2750
2750
Unit 3 Total Actual Rent:
Unit 3 Total Actual Rent:
1590
1590

Building and Construction

Building Area Total:
Building Area Total:
2998
2998
Building Exterior Type:
Building Exterior Type:
Vinyl Siding
Vinyl Siding
Construction Materials:
Construction Materials:
Vinyl Siding
Vinyl Siding
Foundation Details:
Foundation Details:
Full
Full
Levels or Stories:
Levels or Stories:
2
2
Property Age:
Property Age:
110
110
Property Condition:
Property Condition:
Excellent
Excellent
Total Square Feet Living:
Total Square Feet Living:
2998
2998
Year Built Details:
Year Built Details:
Approx
Approx
Year Built:
Year Built:
1915
1915

Other Property Info

Annual Tax Amount:
Annual Tax Amount:
7072
7072
Area:
Area:
Tottenville
Tottenville
City Region:
City Region:
South Shore
South Shore
County:
County:
Richmond
Richmond
MLS Area Minor:
MLS Area Minor:
Tottenville
Tottenville
Parcel Number:
Parcel Number:
08042-0045
08042-0045
Property Subtype:
Property Subtype:
3F
3F
Source Listing Status:
Source Listing Status:
Active
Active
Source Neighborhood:
Source Neighborhood:
Tottenville
Tottenville
Source Property Type:
Source Property Type:
Residential Income
Residential Income
Source System Name:
Source System Name:
C2C
C2C
Tax Block:
Tax Block:
08042
08042
Zoning:
Zoning:
R3X
R3X

Property Price History

for 217-219 Fisher Ave

Date	Event	Price	Price/Sqft	Source
Jun 26, 2025	Listed	$949,999	$317	StatenIsland
Jun 20, 2001	Sold	$244,000	$81	Public Record
Jan 28, 1985	Sold	$72,000	$24	Public Record

Show more Hide

Property Tax History

for 217-219 Fisher Ave

Year	Taxes	Land	Additions	Total Assessment
2024	$7,196	$13,560	$52,860	$66,420
2023	$7,072	$13,560	$44,580	$58,140
2022	$6,608	$13,560	$33,720	$47,280
2021	$6,605	$13,560	$30,060	$43,620
2020	$6,735	$13,560	$29,520	$43,080
2019	$6,339	$13,560	$28,020	$41,580
2018	$6,070	$10,059	$18,961	$29,020
2017	$5,623	$10,238	$17,350	$27,588
2016	$5,228	$10,173	$15,981	$26,154
2015	$5,113	$10,172	$15,978	$26,150
2014	$4,766	$11,477	$13,406	$24,883
2012	$4,185	$12,703	$10,287	$22,990
2010	$3,783	$12,132	$9,663	$21,795
2009	$3,307	$11,983	$9,809	$21,792
2007	$2,757	$4,402	$14,757	$19,159

Show more Hide

Sold Homes

near 217-219 Fisher Ave

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
274 Main St Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$835,000 03/28/2025	1990	5	3	2,940 -58difference	4,750	0.42 mi
274 Main StMF Staten Island, NY 10307 1990 Built 2,940 -58 Sqft 4,750 Lot Size 0.42 mi Distance
68 Craig Ave Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$1,020,000 02/14/2025	2006	4	4	2,821 -177	3,993	0.23 mi
68 Craig AveMF Staten Island, NY 10307 2006 Built 2,821 -177 Sqft 3,993 Lot Size 0.23 mi Distance
341 Swinnerton St Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$990,000 01/21/2025	1992	4	5	3,206 +208	8,000	0.89 mi
341 Swinnerton StMF Staten Island, NY 10307 1992 Built 3,206 +208 Sqft 8,000 Lot Size 0.89 mi Distance
34 Delia Ct Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$875,000 05/08/2025	2001	4	3	2,736 -262	5,272	0.38 mi
34 Delia CtMF Staten Island, NY 10307 2001 Built 2,736 -262 Sqft 5,272 Lot Size 0.38 mi Distance
10 Simon Ct Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$975,000 05/07/2025	2001	6	5	3,290 +292	6,400	0.36 mi
10 Simon CtMF Staten Island, NY 10307 2001 Built 3,290 +292 Sqft 6,400 Lot Size 0.36 mi Distance
229 Yetman Ave Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$1,265,000 01/27/2025	2001	4	5	4,029 +1,031	7,410	0.19 mi
229 Yetman AveMF Staten Island, NY 10307 2001 Built 4,029 +1,031 Sqft 7,410 Lot Size 0.19 mi Distance
66 Joline Ave Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$1,050,000 07/09/2025	—	—	3	2,037 -961	5,485	0.27 mi
66 Joline AveMF Staten Island, NY 10307 — Built 2,037 -961 Sqft 5,485 Lot Size 0.27 mi Distance
112 114 Sprague Ave Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$775,000 05/06/2025	1930	3	1	2,320 -678	8,600	0.33 mi
112 114 Sprague AveMF Staten Island, NY 10307 1930 Built 2,320 -678 Sqft 8,600 Lot Size 0.33 mi Distance
23 Ferguson Ct Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$1,049,000 06/06/2025	2000	3	2	2,650 -348	3,034	0.35 mi
23 Ferguson CtMF Staten Island, NY 10307 2000 Built 2,650 -348 Sqft 3,034 Lot Size 0.35 mi Distance
15 Petunia Ct Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$1,225,000 03/28/2025	2001	5	4	2,160 -838	4,590	0.40 mi
15 Petunia CtMF Staten Island, NY 10307 2001 Built 2,160 -838 Sqft 4,590 Lot Size 0.40 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Homes For Sale

near 217-219 Fisher Ave

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
133 Butler Ave Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$1,328,000 150 days ago	2025	6	2	3,000 +2difference	3,680	0.46 mi
133 Butler AveMF Staten Island, NY 10307 2025 Built 3,000 +2 Sqft 3,680 Lot Size 0.46 mi Distance
184 Connecticut St Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$1,399,000 183 days ago	1995	5	4	3,000 +2	6,000	0.82 mi
184 Connecticut StMF Staten Island, NY 10307 1995 Built 3,000 +2 Sqft 6,000 Lot Size 0.82 mi Distance
141 Butler Ave Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$1,288,000 150 days ago	2025	6	2	3,000 +2	3,858	0.46 mi
141 Butler AveMF Staten Island, NY 10307 2025 Built 3,000 +2 Sqft 3,858 Lot Size 0.46 mi Distance
137 Butler Ave Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$1,288,000 150 days ago	2025	6	2	3,000 +2	3,858	0.46 mi
137 Butler AveMF Staten Island, NY 10307 2025 Built 3,000 +2 Sqft 3,858 Lot Size 0.46 mi Distance
164 Lee Ave Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$1,149,000 33 days ago	1950	5	3	3,044 +46	5,675	0.18 mi
164 Lee AveMF Staten Island, NY 10307 1950 Built 3,044 +46 Sqft 5,675 Lot Size 0.18 mi Distance
237 Swinnerton St Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$1,449,000 45 days ago	2001	5	4	2,736 -262	5,069	0.73 mi
237 Swinnerton StMF Staten Island, NY 10307 2001 Built 2,736 -262 Sqft 5,069 Lot Size 0.73 mi Distance
7546 Amboy Rd Staten Island, NY 10307MF	$1,198,000 703 days ago	2023	6	2	2,700 -298	5,000	0.41 mi
7546 Amboy RdMF Staten Island, NY 10307 2023 Built 2,700 -298 Sqft 5,000 Lot Size 0.41 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Schools

serving 217-219 Fisher Ave

School Name	Rating	Grades	Parent Rating	Distance
Ps 1 Tottenville 58 Summit Street, Staten Island, NY 10307	6 / 10	K−5		0.31 mi
K−5 Grades Parent Rating 0.31 mi Distance
Our Lady Help of Christians School 23 Summit Street, Staten Island, NY 10307	—	PK−8		0.26 mi
PK−8 Grades Parent Rating 0.26 mi Distance
Is 34 Tottenville 528 Academy Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10307	8 / 10	6−8		0.36 mi
6−8 Grades Parent Rating 0.36 mi Distance
Ps 6 Cpl Allan F Kivlehan School 555 Page Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10307	8 / 10	K−5		0.63 mi
K−5 Grades Parent Rating 0.63 mi Distance
Gateway Academy 200 Boscombe Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10309	—	PK−8	—	0.89 mi
PK−8 Grades — Parent Rating 0.89 mi Distance
Gateway Academy 200 Boscombe Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10309	—	K−8		0.85 mi
K−8 Grades Parent Rating 0.85 mi Distance
Perth Amboy Vocational School 457 High Street, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861	6 / 10	9−12		1.10 mi
9−12 Grades Parent Rating 1.10 mi Distance
South Richmond High School Is Ps 25 6581 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island, NY 10309	—	K−12		1.13 mi
K−12 Grades Parent Rating 1.13 mi Distance
Academy For Urban Leadership Charter School 612 Amboy Avenue, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861	1 / 10	7−12	—	1.87 mi
7−12 Grades — Parent Rating 1.87 mi Distance

Show more Hide

School service boundaries are intended to be used as reference only. To verify enrollment eligibility for a property, contact the school directly.

Flood Factor

for 217-219 Fisher Ave

1 ^|10

Minimal

FEMA Zone (Est.)

X (unshaded)

Flood insurance:

Recommended

Flood risks are increasing as sea levels rise and weather patterns change.

This property has a Minimal Flood Factor .
Although flood risks across the country are changing because of the environment, this property is unlikely to flood over the next 30 years.

Flood Factor data provided by FloodFactor.