2 Bay Pl is a 1,614 square foot house on a 7,841 square foot lot with 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. 2 Bay Pl is a house currently priced at $459,999.

What is the price per square foot?

The price per square foot at 2 Bay Pl is $285.

What type of home is 2 Bay Pl?

2 Bay Pl is classified as a single-family residence.

Who is the listing agent or seller?

The listing is provided by Montauk Dunes LLC.

What is the MLS number for this property?

This property is listed on the MLS with ID 852082 from OneKeyMLS.

What is the lot size of this property?

The property sits on a 7,841 square foot lot.

How many photos are available for this home?

DistressedRealEstate.net has 4 photos of 2 Bay Pl.

How much is this home worth?

Based on DistressedRealEstate.net's Bay Shore, NY data, we estimate the home's value is $602,600.

How long has this home been listed on DistressedRealEstate.net?

2 Bay Pl has been listed on DistressedRealEstate.net since March 12, 2021.

How competitive is the market for this home?

Based on DistressedRealEstate.net's market data, we calculate that market competition in 11706, this home's neighborhood, is somewhat competitive. This home is priced approximately 24% below the estimated market value.

What’s the full address of this home?

The full address for this home is 2 Bay Pl, Bay Shore, NY 11706.

2 Bay Pl, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Foreclosure

Last Updated: January 31, 2025

2 Bay Pl, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

For Sale$ 459,999

Foreclosure

MAY 9, 2025

Single Family Home

Town House

For Sale

$459,999

Yard

House View

2 Bay Pl

    
bool(false)

bool(true)

bool(true)

int(0)

For Sale

$459,999

Bay Shore, NY 11706

—

Suffolk County

Favorite

Calculate Flipping Profit

Case Number

604289/2021

Recording Date

Mar 12, 2021 (1,561 days ago)

Latest Document Date

May 9, 2025 (42 days ago)

Judgment Amount

12,345,678.90

Original Loan Amount

12,345,678.90

Summarized Complaint

The text you see blurred has been intentionally replaced to notify you that access to this content requires an active subscription and sufficient REbbons View Credits (RVC). To unlock and view the full information, please ensure you have purchased the necessary tokens and are subscribed to the relevant region. Your subscription and credits will grant you complete access.

This blurred content is a placeholder. To view the full information, you need an active subscription and sufficient RVC tokens. .

Data marked with is not visible to unregistered users

Key Documents of the Case 6

NOTICE Jane Citizen

Jan 30, 2025

NOTICE Jane Everyday

Apr 24, 2024

NOTICE John Doe

Apr 12, 2024

NOTICE John Grey

Sep 6, 2023

NOTICE Jane Silent

Mar 17, 2023

SUMMONS John Standard

Mar 12, 2021

Property Address (By court documents) 1

1.	2 Bay Pl, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Suffolk County, NY
Legal Description of Property District 0500 Section 395.00 Block 000 Lot 000 Parcel ID / Tax Map # / APN 0500-395.00-000-000 The parcel located at the specified block and lot within Suffolk County, as detailed in the plat officially filed with the County Recorder.

Parties 2

Plaintiffs / Petitioners
1.	Jane Placeholder Attorney Represented

Defendants / Respondents
1.	Jane Average Attorney Unrepresented

Legal Representatives 2

	Attorney Name	Client Name
1.	Jane Zero John Basic	CLIENT NAME Plaintiff, Since Mar 12, 2021
Attorney Name Jane Zero Company Name John Basic Office Address BAY SHORE, NY 11706 Phone Number 012-345-6789 Registration Number 0123456789

Show more Hide

Property details for 2 Bay Pl

Estimated Reasonable Offer

$476,000

Status

For Sale

Foreclosure

Yes

Days on market

1,562 days

Type

Single Family Home

Town House

Year Built

1957

Stories

Garage

Yes

Flood Factor

10 / 10

The description and property data below may have been provided by a third party, the homeowner or public records.

Welcome to 2 Bay Place, a beautifully maintained home nestled in one of Bay Shores most desirable neighborhoods. This property offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and convenience, just minutes from the vibrant downtown, South Shore beaches, Fire Island ferries, and the LIRR. Outside, enjoy a private backyard oasis ideal for relaxing, gardening, or summer barbecue. Attached 1 car garage. Whether you're a first-time buyer or looking to settle into a peaceful, well-connected community. Subject is being sold in an upcoming Xome auction. Subject property is being sold occupied and all occupants in AS IS/WHERE IS condition. Neither the seller nor the listing broker can verify the existence of any lease agreement, either written or verbal, or any rental amount being paid, due or owing. Please DO NOT disturb the occupants. Access for the inspections or other purposes is NOT guaranteed- contact the listing broker to confirm if accessible. Buyer is assuming ALL responsibility for any necessary eviction action.

Property facts

Property features

Appliances

Refrigerator

Bedrooms

Bedrooms:
Bedrooms:
4
4

Garage and Parking

Garage Spaces:
Garage Spaces:
1
1

Heating and Cooling

Heating Features:
Heating Features:
Oil
Oil

Homeowners Association

Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees:
Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees:
0
0

Other Rooms

Total Rooms:
Total Rooms:
7
7

Bathrooms

Full Bathrooms:
Full Bathrooms:
2
2
Total Bathrooms:
Total Bathrooms:
2
2

Interior Features

First Floor Bedroom
First Floor Full Bath

Land Info

Lot Size Acres:
Lot Size Acres:
0.1800046
0.1800046
Lot Size Square Feet:
Lot Size Square Feet:
7841
7841

Utilities

Sewer:
Sewer:
Public Sewer
Public Sewer
Water Source:
Water Source:
Public
Public

School Information

Elementary School:
Elementary School:
Contact Agent
Contact Agent
High School District:
High School District:
Islip
Islip
High School:
High School:
Islip High School
Islip High School
Middle School:
Middle School:
Islip Middle School
Islip Middle School

Building and Construction

Architectural Style:
Architectural Style:
Split Level
Split Level
Building Area Source:
Building Area Source:
Public Records
Public Records
Building Area Total:
Building Area Total:
1614
1614
Building Area Units:
Building Area Units:
Square Feet
Square Feet
Construction Materials:
Construction Materials:
Aluminum Siding
Aluminum Siding
Levels:
Levels:
Two
Two
Living Area Source:
Living Area Source:
Public Records
Public Records
Property Age:
Property Age:
68
68
Total Square Feet Living:
Total Square Feet Living:
1614
1614
Year Built:
Year Built:
1957
1957

Other Property Info

Annual Tax Amount:
Annual Tax Amount:
12673.53
12673.53
County:
County:
Suffolk County
Suffolk County
Parcel Number:
Parcel Number:
0500-395-00-03-00-022-000
0500-395-00-03-00-022-000
Postal City:
Postal City:
Bay Shore
Bay Shore
Postal Code Plus 4:
Postal Code Plus 4:
8906
8906
Property Subtype:
Property Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Single Family Residence
Source Listing Status:
Source Listing Status:
Active
Active
Source Property Type:
Source Property Type:
Residential
Residential
Source System Name:
Source System Name:
C2C
C2C
Tax Year:
Tax Year:
2024
2024

Property Price History

for 2 Bay Pl

Date	Event	Price	Price/Sqft	Source
Apr 22, 2025	Listed	$459,999	$285	OneKeyMLS

Property Tax History

for 2 Bay Pl

Year	Taxes	Land	Additions	Total Assessment
2024	$12,673	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2023	$12,673	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2022	$12,854	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2021	$12,428	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2020	$12,108	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2018	$11,776	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2017	$11,680	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2016	$11,606	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2015	$11,600	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2014	$11,415	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2013	$7,222	$9,200	$18,832	$28,032
2012	$9,664	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2011	$9,299	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2010	$8,868	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400
2008	$8,287	$9,200	$29,200	$38,400

Show more Hide

Sold Homes

near 2 Bay Pl

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
10 Grace Ct Islip, NY 11751SF	$705,000 05/05/2025	1957	3	2	1,680 +66difference	6,098	0.35 mi
10 Grace CtSF Islip, NY 11751 1957 Built 1,680 +66 Sqft 6,098 Lot Size 0.35 mi Distance
7 Adelphi St Islip, NY 11751SF	$675,000 05/22/2025	1955	5	2	1,696 +82	12,632	0.39 mi
7 Adelphi StSF Islip, NY 11751 1955 Built 1,696 +82 Sqft 12,632 Lot Size 0.39 mi Distance
24 McKinley St Islip, NY 11751SF	$577,000 05/08/2025	1900	3	1	1,518 -96	13,504	0.85 mi
24 McKinley StSF Islip, NY 11751 1900 Built 1,518 -96 Sqft 13,504 Lot Size 0.85 mi Distance
22 Bay 2nd St Islip, NY 11751SF	$590,000 03/21/2025	1961	3	2	1,433 -181	6,098	0.93 mi
22 Bay 2nd StSF Islip, NY 11751 1961 Built 1,433 -181 Sqft 6,098 Lot Size 0.93 mi Distance
29 Orowoc Dr Islip, NY 11751SF	$550,000 06/09/2025	1922	2	2	1,354 -260	13,504	0.23 mi
29 Orowoc DrSF Islip, NY 11751 1922 Built 1,354 -260 Sqft 13,504 Lot Size 0.23 mi Distance
25 Angela Ln Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$1,050,000 03/24/2025	1971	4	3	2,434 +820	23,522	0.25 mi
25 Angela LnSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1971 Built 2,434 +820 Sqft 23,522 Lot Size 0.25 mi Distance
160 Church Ave Islip, NY 11751SF	$650,000 01/17/2025	1954	3	1	1,200 -414	11,326	0.47 mi
160 Church AveSF Islip, NY 11751 1954 Built 1,200 -414 Sqft 11,326 Lot Size 0.47 mi Distance
199 Raymond St Islip, NY 11751SF	$765,000 02/06/2025	1900	3	2	2,372 +758	6,970	0.60 mi
199 Raymond StSF Islip, NY 11751 1900 Built 2,372 +758 Sqft 6,970 Lot Size 0.60 mi Distance
13 1st St Islip, NY 11751SF	$670,000 04/01/2025	1905	3	3	1,342 -272	7,841	0.60 mi
13 1st StSF Islip, NY 11751 1905 Built 1,342 -272 Sqft 7,841 Lot Size 0.60 mi Distance
267 Smith Ave Islip, NY 11751SF	$690,000 06/12/2025	1902	4	2	1,908 +294	9,148	0.61 mi
267 Smith AveSF Islip, NY 11751 1902 Built 1,908 +294 Sqft 9,148 Lot Size 0.61 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Homes For Sale

near 2 Bay Pl

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
1210 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$649,999 100 days ago	1963	4	3	1,638 +24difference	10,019	1.25 mi
1210 Saxon AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1963 Built 1,638 +24 Sqft 10,019 Lot Size 1.25 mi Distance
52 California Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$624,444 58 days ago	1960	3	2	1,656 +42	7,405	1.69 mi
52 California AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1960 Built 1,656 +42 Sqft 7,405 Lot Size 1.69 mi Distance
1410 Union Blvd Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$550,000 93 days ago	1925	3	2	1,659 +45	11,326	1.81 mi
1410 Union BlvdSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1925 Built 1,659 +45 Sqft 11,326 Lot Size 1.81 mi Distance
17 Abrew St Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$575,000 98 days ago	1956	4	1	1,560 -54	9,148	1.85 mi
17 Abrew StSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1956 Built 1,560 -54 Sqft 9,148 Lot Size 1.85 mi Distance
10 Grace Ct Islip, NY 11751SF	$600,000 141 days ago	1957	3	2	1,680 +66	6,098	0.35 mi
10 Grace CtSF Islip, NY 11751 1957 Built 1,680 +66 Sqft 6,098 Lot Size 0.35 mi Distance
7 Adelphi St Islip, NY 11751SF	$625,000 113 days ago	1955	5	2	1,696 +82	12,632	0.39 mi
7 Adelphi StSF Islip, NY 11751 1955 Built 1,696 +82 Sqft 12,632 Lot Size 0.39 mi Distance
14 Garden Pl Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$735,000 127 days ago	1933	3	2	1,698 +84	8,712	1.95 mi
14 Garden PlSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1933 Built 1,698 +84 Sqft 8,712 Lot Size 1.95 mi Distance
135 Penataquit Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$629,000 75 days ago	1935	3	2	1,700 +86	7,405	1.16 mi
135 Penataquit AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1935 Built 1,700 +86 Sqft 7,405 Lot Size 1.16 mi Distance
24 McKinley St Islip, NY 11751SF	$500,000 136 days ago	1900	3	1	1,518 -96	13,504	0.85 mi
24 McKinley StSF Islip, NY 11751 1900 Built 1,518 -96 Sqft 13,504 Lot Size 0.85 mi Distance
33 Community Rd Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$629,999 86 days ago	1957	3	2	1,500 -114	8,712	1.59 mi
33 Community RdSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1957 Built 1,500 -114 Sqft 8,712 Lot Size 1.59 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Schools

serving 2 Bay Pl

School Name	Rating	Grades	Distance
Commack Road Elementary School 300 Commack Road, Islip, NY 11751	3 / 10	2−5	1.55 mi
2−5 Grades Parent Rating 1.55 mi Distance
St Mary School 16 Harrison Avenue, East Islip, NY 11730	—	PK−8	1.63 mi
PK−8 Grades Parent Rating 1.63 mi Distance
St Peters By The Sea Episcopal Day School 500 Montauk Highway, Bay Shore, NY 11706	—	K−8	2.31 mi
K−8 Grades Parent Rating 2.31 mi Distance
Wing Elementary School 1 Winganhauppauge Road, Islip, NY 11751	—	K−1	1.52 mi
K−1 Grades Parent Rating 1.52 mi Distance
Islip High School 2508 Union Boulevard, Islip, NY 11751	9 / 10	9−12	0.63 mi
9−12 Grades Parent Rating 0.63 mi Distance
Islip Middle School 211 Main Street, Islip, NY 11751	4 / 10	6−8	0.43 mi
6−8 Grades Parent Rating 0.43 mi Distance
St Patrick School MONTAUK HWY, Bay Shore, NY 11706	—	PK−8	1.73 mi
PK−8 Grades Parent Rating 1.73 mi Distance