Past Auction

42 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Last Updated: June 5, 2025

42 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

EMV$ 489,100

Past Auction

NEWJUL 24, 2025

Single Family Home

Town House

Estimated Market ValueEMV

$489,100

42 5th Ave

    
bool(false)

bool(true)

bool(true)

int(0)

Estimated Market ValueEMV

$489,100

Bay Shore, NY 11706

—

Suffolk County

Favorite

Calculate Flipping Profit

Case Number

602888/2023

Recording Date

Feb 3, 2023 (908 days ago)

Latest Document Date

Jul 24, 2025 (6 days ago)

Judgment Amount

12,345,678.90

Original Loan Amount

12,345,678.90

Summarized Complaint

The text you see blurred has been intentionally replaced to notify you that access to this content requires an active subscription and sufficient REbbons View Credits (RVC). To unlock and view the full information, please ensure you have purchased the necessary tokens and are subscribed to the relevant region. Your subscription and credits will grant you complete access.

This blurred content is a placeholder. To view the full information, you need an active subscription and sufficient RVC tokens. .

Data marked with is not visible to unregistered users

Key Documents of the Case 3

NOTICE Jane Q. Public

Jun 5, 2025

NOTICE Jane Noone

Aug 28, 2024

SUMMONS John Faceless

Feb 3, 2023

Property Address (By court documents) 1

1.	42 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Suffolk County, NY
Legal Description of Property District 0500 Section 392.00 Block 000 Lot 000 Parcel ID / Tax Map # / APN 0500-392.00-000-000 The parcel located at the specified block and lot within Suffolk County, as detailed in the plat officially filed with the County Recorder.

Parties 2

Plaintiffs / Petitioners
1.	John Blank Attorney Represented

Defendants / Respondents
1.	John Null Attorney Represented

Legal Representatives 2

	Attorney Name	Client Name
1.	John Typical Jane Random	CLIENT NAME Plaintiff, Since Feb 3, 2023
Attorney Name John Typical Company Name Jane Random Office Address NEW YORK, NY 10004 Phone Number 012-345-6789 Registration Number 0123456789

Show more Hide

Property details for 42 5th Ave

Status

Off Market

Type

Single Family Home

Town House

Year Built

1880

Flood Factor

1 / 10

Last Sold

$421K in 2022

The description and property data below may have been provided by a third party, the homeowner or public records.

42 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 is a Single Family Home built in 1880. This property was last sold for $421,000 in 2022 and currently has an estimated value of $489,100. According to the Bay Shore public records, the property at 42 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 has approximately 1,196 square feet, with a lot size of 6,970 square feet. Nearby schools include Fifth Avenue School and Brook Avenue Elementary School.

Property facts

Property features

Listing information

Year Built:
Year Built:
1880
1880

Location

Zoning:
Zoning:
B
B

Lot size and SQFT

Living Area:
Living Area:
1196
1196

Property Price History

for 42 5th Ave

Date	Event	Price	Price/Sqft	Source
Feb 22, 2022	Sold	$421,000	$352	Public Record
Nov 22, 2021	Sold	$421,000	—	OneKeyMLS
Sep 28, 2021	Sold	$95,000	$79	Public Record
Feb 14, 2011	Listing removed	$270,000	—	OneKeyMLS
Dec 15, 2010	Price Changed	$270,000	—	OneKeyMLS
Nov 18, 2010	Price Changed	$295,000	—	OneKeyMLS
Nov 10, 2010	Price Changed	$309,000	—	OneKeyMLS
Oct 30, 2010	Price Changed	$325,000	—	OneKeyMLS
Oct 28, 2010	Price Changed	$335,999	—	OneKeyMLS
Sep 24, 2010	Listed	$349,999	—	OneKeyMLS

Show more Hide

Property Tax History

for 42 5th Ave

Year	Taxes	Land	Additions	Total Assessment
2024	$9,128	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2023	$8,514	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2022	$7,644	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2021	$7,320	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2020	$6,974	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2018	$6,699	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2017	$6,447	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2016	$6,369	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2015	$6,421	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2014	$6,448	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2013	$6,380	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2012	$6,103	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2011	$5,866	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2010	$5,665	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150
2008	$5,444	$6,500	$19,650	$26,150

Show more Hide

Sold Homes

near 42 5th Ave

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
8 Cottage Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$760,000 04/16/2025	1900	2	2	1,257 +61difference	3,485	0.81 mi
8 Cottage AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1900 Built 1,257 +61 Sqft 3,485 Lot Size 0.81 mi Distance
33 Community Rd Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$610,000 07/22/2025	1957	3	2	1,500 +304	8,712	0.14 mi
33 Community RdSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1957 Built 1,500 +304 Sqft 8,712 Lot Size 0.14 mi Distance
1410 Union Blvd Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$540,000 06/13/2025	1925	3	2	1,659 +463	11,326	0.32 mi
1410 Union BlvdSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1925 Built 1,659 +463 Sqft 11,326 Lot Size 0.32 mi Distance
14 Garden Pl Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$750,000 05/05/2025	1933	3	2	1,698 +502	8,712	0.47 mi
14 Garden PlSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1933 Built 1,698 +502 Sqft 8,712 Lot Size 0.47 mi Distance
527 Lombardy Blvd Brightwaters, NY 11718SF	$749,900 06/26/2025	1910	3	2	1,700 +504	10,454	0.68 mi
527 Lombardy BlvdSF Brightwaters, NY 11718 1910 Built 1,700 +504 Sqft 10,454 Lot Size 0.68 mi Distance
11 S Clinton Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$528,200 03/04/2025	1860	4	3	2,731 +1,535	11,326	0.23 mi
11 S Clinton AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1860 Built 2,731 +1,535 Sqft 11,326 Lot Size 0.23 mi Distance
26 Lanier Ln Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$975,000 03/04/2025	1920	5	2	2,711 +1,515	33,541	0.25 mi
26 Lanier LnSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1920 Built 2,711 +1,515 Sqft 33,541 Lot Size 0.25 mi Distance
68 Johnson Ln Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$699,000 03/19/2025	1954	4	2	2,150 +954	6,534	0.38 mi
68 Johnson LnSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1954 Built 2,150 +954 Sqft 6,534 Lot Size 0.38 mi Distance
216 Windsor Ave Brightwaters, NY 11718SF	$1,300,000 06/27/2025	2023	4	4	3,800 +2,604	—	0.56 mi
216 Windsor AveSF Brightwaters, NY 11718 2023 Built 3,800 +2,604 Sqft — Lot Size 0.56 mi Distance
328 Plymouth Ave Brightwaters, NY 11718SF	$910,000 07/24/2025	1957	5	2	3,098 +1,902	10,454	0.65 mi
328 Plymouth AveSF Brightwaters, NY 11718 1957 Built 3,098 +1,902 Sqft 10,454 Lot Size 0.65 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Homes For Sale

near 42 5th Ave

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
14 Chenango Dr Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$649,990 62 days ago	1961	3	1	1,200 +4difference	4,792	1.22 mi
14 Chenango DrSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1961 Built 1,200 +4 Sqft 4,792 Lot Size 1.22 mi Distance
939 Thompson Dr Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$558,000 201 days ago	1956	3	2	1,190 -6	11,326	1.65 mi
939 Thompson DrSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1956 Built 1,190 -6 Sqft 11,326 Lot Size 1.65 mi Distance
1343 Thompson Dr Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$525,000 138 days ago	1955	4	1	1,214 +18	10,890	1.67 mi
1343 Thompson DrSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1955 Built 1,214 +18 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 1.67 mi Distance
34 Howells Rd Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$299,000 239 days ago	1950	4	2	1,176 -20	6,098	0.54 mi
34 Howells RdSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1950 Built 1,176 -20 Sqft 6,098 Lot Size 0.54 mi Distance
529 Myrtle Ave West Islip, NY 11795SF	$699,000 86 days ago	1957	3	2	1,254 +58	7,841	1.86 mi
529 Myrtle AveSF West Islip, NY 11795 1957 Built 1,254 +58 Sqft 7,841 Lot Size 1.86 mi Distance
1381 Manatuck Blvd Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$559,900 43 days ago	1914	3	1	1,128 -68	11,761	1.40 mi
1381 Manatuck BlvdSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1914 Built 1,128 -68 Sqft 11,761 Lot Size 1.40 mi Distance
1426 Brentwood Rd Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$639,999 154 days ago	1958	5	3	1,296 +100	9,148	1.92 mi
1426 Brentwood RdSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1958 Built 1,296 +100 Sqft 9,148 Lot Size 1.92 mi Distance
1011 Carll Dr Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$539,000 97 days ago	1955	3	1	1,300 +104	7,405	1.48 mi
1011 Carll DrSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1955 Built 1,300 +104 Sqft 7,405 Lot Size 1.48 mi Distance
541 Peters Blvd Brightwaters, NY 11718SF	$714,900 94 days ago	1948	3	2	1,300 +104	14,810	1.07 mi
541 Peters BlvdSF Brightwaters, NY 11718 1948 Built 1,300 +104 Sqft 14,810 Lot Size 1.07 mi Distance
1436 Lombardy Blvd Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$499,000 98 days ago	1952	3	1	1,306 +110	6,970	1.72 mi
1436 Lombardy BlvdSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1952 Built 1,306 +110 Sqft 6,970 Lot Size 1.72 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Home Value

for 42 5th Ave

Estimated values are not a substitute for professional expertise. Contact your RE agent for a market assessment.

Schools

serving 42 5th Ave

School Name	Rating	Grades	Parent Rating	Distance
Fifth Avenue School 217 5th Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706	—	K−2		0.76 mi
K−2 Grades Parent Rating 0.76 mi Distance
Heritage Christian Academy 1380 5th Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706	—	PK−5	—	1.43 mi
PK−5 Grades — Parent Rating 1.43 mi Distance
Bay Shore Senior High School 155 Third Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706	5 / 10	9−12		0.70 mi
9−12 Grades Parent Rating 0.70 mi Distance
Bay Shore Middle School 393 Brook Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706	5 / 10	6−8		1.31 mi
6−8 Grades Parent Rating 1.31 mi Distance
Brook Avenue Elementary School 45 Brook Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706	—	K−2		0.94 mi
K−2 Grades Parent Rating 0.94 mi Distance
St Patrick School MONTAUK HWY, Bay Shore, NY 11706	—	PK−8		0.43 mi
PK−8 Grades Parent Rating 0.43 mi Distance
St Peters By The Sea Episcopal Day School 500 Montauk Highway, Bay Shore, NY 11706	—	K−8		1.16 mi
K−8 Grades Parent Rating 1.16 mi Distance

Show more Hide

School service boundaries are intended to be used as reference only. To verify enrollment eligibility for a property, contact the school directly.

Flood Factor

for 42 5th Ave

1 ^|10

Minimal

FEMA Zone (Est.)

X (unshaded)

Flood insurance:

Recommended

Flood risks are increasing as sea levels rise and weather patterns change.

This property has a Minimal Flood Factor .
Although flood risks across the country are changing because of the environment, this property is unlikely to flood over the next 30 years.

Flood Factor data provided by FloodFactor.

42 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Suffolk County

42 5th Ave bool(false) bool(true) bool(true) int(0)

42 5th Ave

bool(false) bool(true) bool(true) int(0)