95 Gaynor St, Staten Island, NY 10309

Richmond County

Last Updated: May 16, 2025

Pre-Foreclosure: Lis Pendens, Estimated Market Value $1,998,200

Description: 95 Gaynor St, Staten Island, NY 10309 is a Multi Family Home built in 1997. This property was last sold for $1,135,000 in 2005 and currently has an estimated value of $1,998,200. According to the Staten Island public records, the property at 95 Gaynor St, Staten Island, NY 10309 has approximately 3,800 square feet, with a lot size of 11,926 square feet. Nearby schools include Kathleen Grimm School For Leadership, Ps 3 The Margaret Gioiosa School and South Richmond High School Is Ps 25.

Last Sold Price: $1,135,000
Price to EMV Ratio: 74.00%
EARV Ratio: 72.00%
3,800 sqft
11,926 lot size
Year Built: 1997
Latitude: 40.5261400, Longitude: -74.2195090
95 Gaynor St
Staten Island, NY 10309
Foreclosure History
Lis Pendens
Property details
The description and property data below may have been provided by a third party, the homeowner or public records.
95 Gaynor St, Staten Island, NY 10309 is a Multi Family Home built in 1997. This property was last sold for $1,135,000 in 2005 and currently has an estimated value of $1,998,200. According to the Staten Island public records, the property at 95 Gaynor St, Staten Island, NY 10309 has approximately 3,800 square feet, with a lot size of 11,926 square feet. Nearby schools include Kathleen Grimm School For Leadership, Ps 3 The Margaret Gioiosa School and South Richmond High School Is Ps 25.
Property facts
Primary Land Use and Tax Lot Information
  • 95 GAYNOR STREET, 10309
  • DOB Overview:
  • Building Class:
    B2
    Two Family Dwellings: Frame
  • Year Built:
    1997
  • Number of Buildings:
    1
  • Floors on Main Building:
    2
  • Building Dimensions:
    60'35'
  • Actual Square Footage:
    3,800
  • Calculated Square Footage:
    4,200
  • Residential Floor Area:
    3,800
  • Total Units:
    2
  • Residential Units:
    2
  • Extension:
    None
  • Basement:
    Below grade full basement
  • Proximity:
    Detached
  • Address:
    95 GAYNOR STREET
  • Zip Code:
    10309
  • Borough:
    Staten Island (5)
  • Block — Lot:
    7498 — 58
  • BBLE:
    5074980058
  • Lot Buildings:
    BIN
    Name
    5127708 95 GAYNOR STREET

  • Ownership:

  • Land Use:
    01
    One & Two Family Buildings
  • Lot Dimensions:
    87.58'136.17'
  • Calculated Lot Perimeter:
    453.64 ft
  • Acres:
    0.27
  • Lot Area:
    11,926
  • Lot Type:
    Inside
  • Zoning Districts:
    R3X
    Lower-density residence district
  • Special Purpose Districts:
    SRD
    Special South Richmond Development District
  • Zoning Map:

  • Actual FAR:
    0.32
  • Max Residential FAR:
    0.50
  • Max Commercial FAR:
    0
  • Max Facility FAR:
    1

  • Max Residential Sqft:
    5,963
  • Buildable Residential Sqft:
    2,163
  • Residential Area Distribution:
Real Property Records
Document Type
Property Price History
Date Event Price
Dec 19, 2019 Listing removed $1,249,000
Jan 2, 2015 Listing removed $798,876
Property Tax History
Year Taxes Assessment
2024 $15,777 $89,040
2023 $15,623 $91,200
Sold Homes
Address Price Beds Baths
Homes For Sale
Address Price Beds Baths
Home Value
Estimated values are not a substitute for professional expertise. Contact your RE agent for a market assessment.
Schools
School Name Rating
Kathleen Grimm School For Leadership
644 Bloomingdale Road, NY 10309
8 / 10
Ps 3 The Margaret Gioiosa School
80 South Goff Avenue, NY 10309
9 / 10
Is 34 Tottenville
528 Academy Avenue, NY 10307
8 / 10
Data provided by GreatSchools.org © 2025. All Rights Reserved.
School service boundaries are intended to be used as reference only. To verify enrollment eligibility for a property, contact the school directly.
Flood Factor
Flood Factor Score: 1 Flood Factor Score: 1 Flood Factor Score: 1 Flood Factor Score: 1
1 |10
Minimal
Flood Factor
FEMA Zone (Est.)
X (unshaded)
Flood insurance:
Recommended
Flood risks are increasing as sea levels rise and weather patterns change.
This property has a Minimal Flood Factor .
Although flood risks across the country are changing because of the environment, this property is unlikely to flood over the next 30 years.
Flood Factor data provided by FloodFactor.