What is 74 Webster Ave?

74 Webster Ave is a 1,764 square foot house on a 10,019 square foot lot with 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. 74 Webster Ave is a house currently priced at $749,990.

What is the price per square foot?

The price per square foot at 74 Webster Ave is $425.

What type of home is 74 Webster Ave?

74 Webster Ave is classified as a single-family residence.

Who is the listing agent or seller?

The listing is provided by Century 21 AA Realty.

What is the MLS number for this property?

This property is listed on the MLS with ID 866579 from OneKeyMLS.

What is the lot size of this property?

The property sits on a 10,019 square foot lot.

How many photos are available for this home?

DistressedRealEstate.net has 40 photos of 74 Webster Ave.

How much is this home worth?

Based on DistressedRealEstate.net's West Islip, NY data, we estimate the home's value is $606,400.

How long has this home been listed on DistressedRealEstate.net?

74 Webster Ave has been listed on DistressedRealEstate.net since May 27, 2025.

When was this home built?

74 Webster Ave was built in 1935.

When was this home last sold?

74 Webster Ave was last sold in September 1, 1993.

How competitive is the market for this home?

Based on DistressedRealEstate.net's market data, we calculate that market competition in 11795, this home's neighborhood, is somewhat competitive. This home is priced approximately 24% above the estimated market value.

What’s the full address of this home?

The full address for this home is 74 Webster Ave, West Islip, NY 11795.

74 Webster Ave, West Islip, NY 11795

Foreclosure

Last Updated: May 27, 2025

74 Webster Ave, West Islip, NY, 11795

For Sale$ 749,990

Foreclosure

OCT 30, 2024

Single Family Home

Town House

For Sale

$749,990

Yard

Yard

74 Webster Ave

    
bool(false)

bool(true)

bool(true)

int(0)

For Sale

$749,990

West Islip, NY 11795

—

Suffolk County

Favorite

Calculate Flipping Profit

Case Number

617676/2018

Recording Date

Sep 11, 2018 (2,476 days ago)

Latest Document Date

Oct 30, 2024 (235 days ago)

Judgment Amount

12,345,678.90

Original Loan Amount

12,345,678.90

Summarized Complaint

The text you see blurred has been intentionally replaced to notify you that access to this content requires an active subscription and sufficient REbbons View Credits (RVC). To unlock and view the full information, please ensure you have purchased the necessary tokens and are subscribed to the relevant region. Your subscription and credits will grant you complete access.

This blurred content is a placeholder. To view the full information, you need an active subscription and sufficient RVC tokens. .

Data marked with is not visible to unregistered users

Key Documents of the Case 2

	Name	Recording Date
2.	JUDGMENT John Void Jan 24, 2020	Jan 24, 2020
Judgment Date Dec 30, 2019 Debt Amount 12,345,678.90 Judgment Amount 12,345,678.90 Total Costs 12,345,678.90 Costs 12,345,678.90 Disbursements 12,345,678.90 Document Summary The text you see blurred has been intentionally replaced to notify you that access to this content requires an active subscription and sufficient REbbons View Credits (RVC). To unlock and view the full information, please ensure you have purchased the necessary tokens and are subscribed to the relevant region. Your subscription and credits will grant you complete access. This blurred content is a placeholder. To view the full information, you need an active subscription and sufficient RVC tokens. .
1.	SUMMONS Jane Citizen Sep 11, 2018	Sep 11, 2018
Principal Balance 12,345,678.90 Original Loan Amount 12,345,678.90 Default Amount 12,345,678.90 Mortgage Origination Date Month, Year Interest Start Date Month, Year Default Date Month, Year Principal Balance Date Month, Year Complaint Allegations This blurred content is a placeholder. To view the full information, you need an active subscription and sufficient RVC tokens. Compliance Legal Plaintiff has complied with LAW SECTION and LAW SECTION. Summarized Complaint The text you see blurred has been intentionally replaced to notify you that access to this content requires an active subscription and sufficient REbbons View Credits (RVC). To unlock and view the full information, please ensure you have purchased the necessary tokens and are subscribed to the relevant region. Your subscription and credits will grant you complete access. This blurred content is a placeholder. To view the full information, you need an active subscription and sufficient RVC tokens. . Court Document View Details

Property Address (By court documents) 1

1.	74 Webster Ave, West Islip, NY 11795 Suffolk County, NY
Legal Description of Property District 0500 Section 336.00 Block 000 Lot 000 Parcel ID / Tax Map # / APN 0500-336.00-000-000 The parcel located at the specified block and lot within Suffolk County, as detailed in the plat officially filed with the County Recorder.

Parties 2

Plaintiffs / Petitioners
1.	Generic Jane Attorney Represented

Defendants / Respondents
1.	John Silent Attorney Unrepresented

Legal Representatives 2

	Attorney Name	Client Name
1.	John Normal John Smith	CLIENT NAME Plaintiff, Since Feb 4, 2019
Attorney Name John Normal Company Name John Smith Office Address UNIONDALE, NY 11556 Phone Number 012-345-6789 Registration Number 0123456789
2.	Jane Characteristic	CLIENT NAME Plaintiff, Since May 14, 2019
Attorney Name Jane Characteristic Registration Number 0123456789

Show more Hide

Property details for 74 Webster Ave

Estimated Reasonable Offer

$479,000

Status

For Sale

Foreclosure

Yes

Days on market

25 days

Type

Single Family Home

Town House

Year Built

1935

Stories

Garage

Yes

Flood Factor

1 / 10

Last Sold

$155K in 1993

The description and property data below may have been provided by a third party, the homeowner or public records.

Welcome to 74 Webster Avenue! This fully dormered, expanded colonial cape features a king size master bedroom plus 2 or 3 additional super spacious bedrooms. There are 3 full bathrooms. Other amenities included an updated kitchen with granite counter tops, breakfast bar, large dining area, living room or easy home office plus an L-shaped multipurpose room can be living room, playroom, or 4th bedroom. In addition there is an enclosed breezeway with easy access to the attached 1.5 car garage and basement. 150 amp electric. This property features a fabulous backyard with an in ground swimming pool, custom pavers, in ground sprinklers, storage shed with basement, vinyl fencing and more. All situated on park like, private 1/4 acre corner property. Convenient to schools, house of worship, shopping, parks and more! Come take a look!

Property facts

Property features

Home Features

Other Equipment:
Other Equipment:
Pool Equip/Cover
Pool Equip/Cover

Homeowners Association

Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees:
Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees:
0
0

Pool and Spa

Pool Features:
Pool Features:
In Ground
In Ground

Bathrooms

Full Bathrooms:
Full Bathrooms:
3
3
Total Bathrooms:
Total Bathrooms:
3
3

Heating and Cooling

Cooling Features:
Cooling Features:
Wall/Window Unit(s)
Wall/Window Unit(s)
Heating Features:
Heating Features:
Baseboard, Hot Water
Baseboard, Hot Water

Kitchen and Dining

Dining Area Level:
Dining Area Level:
First
First
Kitchen Level:
Kitchen Level:
First
First

Bedrooms

Bedroom 2 Level:
Bedroom 2 Level:
Second
Second
Bedroom 3 Level:
Bedroom 3 Level:
Second
Second
Bedrooms:
Bedrooms:
4
4

Exterior and Lot Features

Fencing:
Fencing:
Back Yard, Vinyl
Back Yard, Vinyl
Other Structures:
Other Structures:
Shed(s)
Shed(s)
Patio And Porch Features:
Patio And Porch Features:
Patio
Patio

Garage and Parking

Garage Spaces:
Garage Spaces:
1
1
Parking Features:
Parking Features:
Driveway, Garage
Driveway, Garage
Parking Total:
Parking Total:
4
4

Land Info

Lot Description:
Lot Description:
Corner Lot, Level, Near Public Transit, Near School, Near Shops, Sprinklers In Front, Sprinklers In Rear
Corner Lot, Level, Near Public Transit, Near School, Near Shops, Sprinklers In Front, Sprinklers In Rear
Lot Size Acres:
Lot Size Acres:
0.23
0.23
Lot Size Dimensions:
Lot Size Dimensions:
100 x 100
100 x 100
Lot Size Square Feet:
Lot Size Square Feet:
10019
10019

Other Rooms

Basement Description:
Basement Description:
Full
Full
Basement Features:
Basement Features:
Full
Full
Living Room Level:
Living Room Level:
First
First
Total Rooms:
Total Rooms:
7
7

Utilities

Electricity Connected
Sewer:
Sewer:
Public Sewer
Public Sewer
Water Connected
Water Source:
Water Source:
Public
Public

School Information

Elementary School District:
Elementary School District:
West Islip
West Islip
Elementary School:
Elementary School:
Manetuck Elementary School
Manetuck Elementary School
High School District:
High School District:
West Islip
West Islip
High School:
High School:
West Islip Senior High School
West Islip Senior High School
Middle School:
Middle School:
Udall Road Middle School
Udall Road Middle School
Middle or Junior School District:
Middle or Junior School District:
West Islip
West Islip

Interior Features

Ceiling Fan(s)
Eat-in Kitchen
First Floor Bedroom
First Floor Full Bath
Flooring:
Flooring:
Hardwood, Laminate, Tile
Hardwood, Laminate, Tile
Formal Dining
Granite Counters
Pantry

Appliances

Dishwasher
Dryer
Electric Oven
Electric Range
Laundry Features:
Laundry Features:
In Basement
In Basement
Microwave
Oil Water Heater
Refrigerator
Washer

Building and Construction

Architectural Style:
Architectural Style:
Exp Cape
Exp Cape
Attic:
Attic:
Partial
Partial
Building Area Units:
Building Area Units:
Square Feet
Square Feet
Construction Materials:
Construction Materials:
Brick, Vinyl Siding
Brick, Vinyl Siding
Foundation Details:
Foundation Details:
Block, Concrete Perimeter
Block, Concrete Perimeter
Levels:
Levels:
Two
Two
Living Area Source:
Living Area Source:
Public Records
Public Records
Property Age:
Property Age:
90
90
Total Square Feet Living:
Total Square Feet Living:
1764
1764
Year Built:
Year Built:
1935
1935

Other Property Info

Annual Tax Amount:
Annual Tax Amount:
14921.00
14921.00
County:
County:
Suffolk County
Suffolk County
Directions:
Directions:
Udall Road to Webster Avenue or Hunter Avenue to Toomey Road to Webster Avenue
Udall Road to Webster Avenue or Hunter Avenue to Toomey Road to Webster Avenue
Parcel Number:
Parcel Number:
0500-336-00-03-00-015-000
0500-336-00-03-00-015-000
Postal City:
Postal City:
West Islip
West Islip
Postal Code Plus 4:
Postal Code Plus 4:
1338
1338
Property Subtype:
Property Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Single Family Residence
Source Listing Status:
Source Listing Status:
Active
Active
Source Property Type:
Source Property Type:
Residential
Residential
Source System Name:
Source System Name:
C2C
C2C
Tax Block:
Tax Block:
0003
0003
Tax Year:
Tax Year:
2025
2025

Property Price History

for 74 Webster Ave

Date	Event	Price	Price/Sqft	Source
May 27, 2025	Listed	$749,990	$425	OneKeyMLS
Jun 4, 2011	Listing removed	$369,990	—	OneKeyMLS
May 21, 2011	Listed	$369,990	—	OneKeyMLS
Sep 1, 1993	Sold	$155,000	$88	Public Record

Show more Hide

Property Tax History

for 74 Webster Ave

Year	Taxes	Land	Additions	Total Assessment
2021	$12,854	$8,000	$40,600	$48,600
2017	$11,944	$8,000	$40,600	$48,600
2016	$12,123	$8,000	$40,600	$48,600
2015	$12,404	$8,000	$40,600	$48,600
2014	$12,323	$8,000	$40,600	$48,600
2013	$12,017	$8,000	$40,600	$48,600
2012	$11,686	$8,000	$40,600	$48,600
2011	$11,372	$8,000	$40,600	$48,600
2010	$10,715	$8,000	$40,600	$48,600
2008	$10,118	$8,000	$40,600	$48,600
2007	$9,577	$8,000	$40,600	$48,600

Show more Hide

Sold Homes

near 74 Webster Ave

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
28 W Oakdale St Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$655,000 06/18/2025	1969	3	2	1,758 -6difference	10,890	0.87 mi
28 W Oakdale StSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1969 Built 1,758 -6 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 0.87 mi Distance
62 Kennedy Ave North Babylon, NY 11703SF	$600,000 01/09/2025	1962	4	2	1,739 -25	4,400	0.97 mi
62 Kennedy AveSF North Babylon, NY 11703 1962 Built 1,739 -25 Sqft 4,400 Lot Size 0.97 mi Distance
4 Breslau St Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$618,000 01/10/2025	1955	4	2	1,800 +36	10,890	0.42 mi
4 Breslau StSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1955 Built 1,800 +36 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 0.42 mi Distance
96 Rutledge Rd North Babylon, NY 11703SF	$650,000 05/23/2025	1954	5	1	1,700 -64	8,550	0.68 mi
96 Rutledge RdSF North Babylon, NY 11703 1954 Built 1,700 -64 Sqft 8,550 Lot Size 0.68 mi Distance
48 Boulevard Ave West Islip, NY 11795SF	$665,250 01/09/2025	1961	3	2	1,678 -86	7,405	0.43 mi
48 Boulevard AveSF West Islip, NY 11795 1961 Built 1,678 -86 Sqft 7,405 Lot Size 0.43 mi Distance
498 Kime Ave West Islip, NY 11795SF	$675,000 06/11/2025	1959	3	2	1,859 +95	10,890	0.20 mi
498 Kime AveSF West Islip, NY 11795 1959 Built 1,859 +95 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 0.20 mi Distance
815 Udall Rd West Islip, NY 11795SF	$560,000 05/14/2025	1951	4	2	1,460 -304	23,958	0.32 mi
815 Udall RdSF West Islip, NY 11795 1951 Built 1,460 -304 Sqft 23,958 Lot Size 0.32 mi Distance
28 Doncaster Ave West Islip, NY 11795SF	$756,000 01/28/2025	1957	3	3	2,350 +586	10,890	0.40 mi
28 Doncaster AveSF West Islip, NY 11795 1957 Built 2,350 +586 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 0.40 mi Distance
39 Penney St West Islip, NY 11795SF	$735,000 04/29/2025	1950	5	3	2,743 +979	10,890	0.43 mi
39 Penney StSF West Islip, NY 11795 1950 Built 2,743 +979 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 0.43 mi Distance
1017 Fire Island Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$495,000 12/31/2024	1953	3	1	1,170 -594	10,890	0.50 mi
1017 Fire Island AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1953 Built 1,170 -594 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 0.50 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Homes For Sale

near 74 Webster Ave

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
73 Lincoln Ave Deer Park, NY 11729SF	$685,000 30 days ago	1972	3	2	1,765 +1difference	6,750	1.26 mi
73 Lincoln AveSF Deer Park, NY 11729 1972 Built 1,765 +1 Sqft 6,750 Lot Size 1.26 mi Distance
24 Southwood Ln North Babylon, NY 11703SF	$625,000 58 days ago	1953	4	2	1,760 -4	11,750	1.59 mi
24 Southwood LnSF North Babylon, NY 11703 1953 Built 1,760 -4 Sqft 11,750 Lot Size 1.59 mi Distance
1358 Manor Ln Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$635,000 38 days ago	1954	5	2	1,759 -5	14,810	1.15 mi
1358 Manor LnSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1954 Built 1,759 -5 Sqft 14,810 Lot Size 1.15 mi Distance
28 W Oakdale St Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$615,000 78 days ago	1969	3	2	1,758 -6	10,890	0.87 mi
28 W Oakdale StSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1969 Built 1,758 -6 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 0.87 mi Distance
1181 Ocean Ave Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$640,000 80 days ago	1962	4	2	1,772 +8	10,454	1.49 mi
1181 Ocean AveSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1962 Built 1,772 +8 Sqft 10,454 Lot Size 1.49 mi Distance
760 Higbie Ln West Islip, NY 11795SF	$595,000 53 days ago	1958	4	3	1,749 -15	10,890	0.61 mi
760 Higbie LnSF West Islip, NY 11795 1958 Built 1,749 -15 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 0.61 mi Distance
46 Sunburst Dr Deer Park, NY 11729SF	$680,000 19 days ago	1960	4	2	1,788 +24	10,000	1.65 mi
46 Sunburst DrSF Deer Park, NY 11729 1960 Built 1,788 +24 Sqft 10,000 Lot Size 1.65 mi Distance
84 Hiawatha Dr Brightwaters, NY 11718SF	$649,990 73 days ago	2025	3	2	1,736 -28	—	1.87 mi
84 Hiawatha DrSF Brightwaters, NY 11718 2025 Built 1,736 -28 Sqft — Lot Size 1.87 mi Distance
10 Fern Pl Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$549,900 52 days ago	1956	4	2	1,800 +36	12,197	1.54 mi
10 Fern PlSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1956 Built 1,800 +36 Sqft 12,197 Lot Size 1.54 mi Distance
5 Krause St Bay Shore, NY 11706SF	$559,000 51 days ago	1957	4	2	1,800 +36	16,553	1.21 mi
5 Krause StSF Bay Shore, NY 11706 1957 Built 1,800 +36 Sqft 16,553 Lot Size 1.21 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Schools

serving 74 Webster Ave

School Name	Rating	Grades	Parent Rating	Distance
Beach Street Middle School 17 Beach Street, West Islip, NY 11795	6 / 10	6−8		1.79 mi
6−8 Grades Parent Rating 1.79 mi Distance
West Islip Senior High School 1 LION'S PATH, West Islip, NY 11795	9 / 10	9−12		2.02 mi
9−12 Grades Parent Rating 2.02 mi Distance
Paul J Bellew Elementary School 25 Higbie Lane, West Islip, NY 11795	7 / 10	K−5		2.18 mi
K−5 Grades Parent Rating 2.18 mi Distance
Manetuck Elementary School 800 Van Buren Avenue, West Islip, NY 11795	5 / 10	K−5		0.14 mi
K−5 Grades Parent Rating 0.14 mi Distance
Oquenock Elementary School 425 Spruce Avenue, West Islip, NY 11795	3 / 10	K−5		0.89 mi
K−5 Grades Parent Rating 0.89 mi Distance
Heritage Christian Academy 1380 5th Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706	—	PK−5	—	2.13 mi
PK−5 Grades — Parent Rating 2.13 mi Distance
Udall Road Middle School 900 Udall Road, West Islip, NY 11795	6 / 10	6−8		0.17 mi
6−8 Grades Parent Rating 0.17 mi Distance

Show more Hide

School service boundaries are intended to be used as reference only. To verify enrollment eligibility for a property, contact the school directly.

Flood Factor

for 74 Webster Ave

1 ^|10

Minimal

FEMA Zone (Est.)

X (unshaded)

Flood insurance:

Recommended

Flood risks are increasing as sea levels rise and weather patterns change.

This property has a Minimal Flood Factor .
Although flood risks across the country are changing because of the environment, this property is unlikely to flood over the next 30 years.

Flood Factor data provided by FloodFactor.