41 Broadway is a 1,600 square foot house on a 9,583 square foot lot with 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. 41 Broadway is a house currently priced at $499,999.

What is the price per square foot?

The price per square foot at 41 Broadway is $312.

What type of home is 41 Broadway?

41 Broadway is classified as a single-family residence.

Who is the listing agent or seller?

The listing is provided by Signature Premier Properties.

What is the MLS number for this property?

This property is listed on the MLS with ID 889937 from OneKeyMLS.

What is the lot size of this property?

The property sits on a 9,583 square foot lot.

How many photos are available for this home?

DistressedRealEstate.net has 19 photos of 41 Broadway.

How much is this home worth?

Based on DistressedRealEstate.net's Shirley, NY data, we estimate the home's value is $482,700.

How long has this home been listed on DistressedRealEstate.net?

41 Broadway has been listed on DistressedRealEstate.net since July 21, 2025.

When was this home last sold?

41 Broadway was last sold in September 24, 2001.

How competitive is the market for this home?

Based on DistressedRealEstate.net's market data, we calculate that market competition in 11967, this home's neighborhood, is somewhat competitive. This home is priced approximately 4% above the estimated market value.

What’s the full address of this home?

The full address for this home is 41 Broadway, Shirley, NY 11967.

41 Broadway, Shirley, NY 11967

Past Auction

Last Updated: August 13, 2025

41 Broadway, Shirley, NY, 11967

For Sale$ 499,999

Past Auction

JUL 11, 2025

Single Family Home

Town House

For Sale

$499,999

Front

Garage

41 Broadway

    
bool(false)

bool(true)

bool(true)

int(0)

For Sale

$499,999

Shirley, NY 11967

—

Suffolk County

Favorite

Calculate Flipping Profit

Case Number

619585/2023

Recording Date

Aug 7, 2023 (745 days ago)

Latest Document Date

Jul 11, 2025 (41 days ago)

Judgment Amount

12,345,678.90

Original Loan Amount

12,345,678.90

Summarized Complaint

The text you see blurred has been intentionally replaced to notify you that access to this content requires an active subscription and sufficient REbbons View Credits (RVC). To unlock and view the full information, please ensure you have purchased the necessary tokens and are subscribed to the relevant region. Your subscription and credits will grant you complete access.

This blurred content is a placeholder. To view the full information, you need an active subscription and sufficient RVC tokens. .

Data marked with is not visible to unregistered users

Key Documents of the Case 2

NOTICE John Public

Jun 5, 2025

SUMMONS Jane Usual

Aug 7, 2023

Property Address (By court documents) 1

1.	41 Broadway, Shirley, NY 11967 Suffolk County, NY
Legal Description of Property District 0200 Section 907.00 Block 000 Lot 000 Parcel ID / Tax Map # / APN 0200-907.00-000-000 The parcel located at the specified block and lot within Suffolk County, as detailed in the plat officially filed with the County Recorder.

Parties 2

Plaintiffs / Petitioners
1.	Average Joe Attorney Represented

Defendants / Respondents
1.	John Usual Attorney Represented

Legal Representatives 2

	Attorney Name	Client Name
1.	John Noone John Simple	CLIENT NAME Plaintiff, Since Aug 7, 2023
Attorney Name John Noone Company Name John Simple Office Address WESTBURY, NY 11590 Phone Number 012-345-6789 Registration Number 0123456789
2.	Jane Characteristic John Stereotypical	CLIENT NAME Plaintiff, Since Jan 22, 2025
Attorney Name Jane Characteristic Company Name John Stereotypical Office Address WESTBURY, NY 11590 Phone Number 012-345-6789 Registration Number 0123456789

Show more Hide

Property details for 41 Broadway

Status

For Sale

Days on market

31 days

Type

Single Family Home

Town House

Year Built

1976

Stories

Garage

Yes

Flood Factor

1 / 10

Last Sold

$145K in 2001

The description and property data below may have been provided by a third party, the homeowner or public records.

Welcome to 41 Broadway in Shirley! This charming 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath colonial sits on an expansive double lot, offering both space and privacy. Sale includes both lots, 2nd lot directly behind that connects to Lexington Rd. The home features a bright and spacious layout with beautiful hardwood floors, a cozy living room, den with a wood-burning stove, formal dining room, half bath and an open-concept kitchen with dining area ideal for entertaining. Upstairs you'll find generously sized bedrooms and a full bath. Step outside to enjoy the large backyard, complete with an above-ground pool, elevated deck, and plenty of room to garden, entertain, or just relax. Additional highlights include a one-car garage, central air, and a prime location near schools, parks, and major highways. With its rare double lot and functional layout, this home offers exceptional value and endless potential. Dont miss the opportunity to make this your own!

Property facts

Property features

Garage and Parking

Garage Spaces:
Garage Spaces:
1
1

Homeowners Association

Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees:
Calculated Total Monthly Association Fees:
0
0

Kitchen and Dining

Dining Area Level:
Dining Area Level:
First
First
Kitchen Level:
Kitchen Level:
First
First

Land Info

Lot Size Acres:
Lot Size Acres:
0.22
0.22
Lot Size Square Feet:
Lot Size Square Feet:
9583
9583

Bathrooms

1/2 Bathrooms:
1/2 Bathrooms:
1
1
Full Bathrooms:
Full Bathrooms:
1
1
Total Bathrooms:
Total Bathrooms:
2
2

Bedrooms

Bedroom 2 Level:
Bedroom 2 Level:
Second
Second
Bedroom 3 Level:
Bedroom 3 Level:
Second
Second
Bedrooms:
Bedrooms:
3
3

Heating and Cooling

Cooling Features:
Cooling Features:
Central Air
Central Air
Heating Features:
Heating Features:
Hot Water, Oil
Hot Water, Oil
Number of Fireplaces:
Number of Fireplaces:
1
1

Interior Features

Eat-in Kitchen
Formal Dining
Storage

Other Rooms

Den Level:
Den Level:
First
First
Living Room Level:
Living Room Level:
First
First
Total Rooms:
Total Rooms:
8
8

Appliances

Dryer
Electric Range
Refrigerator
Washer

School Information

Elementary School District:
Elementary School District:
William Floyd
William Floyd
Elementary School:
Elementary School:
William Floyd Elementary School
William Floyd Elementary School
High School District:
High School District:
William Floyd
William Floyd
High School:
High School:
William Floyd High School
William Floyd High School
Middle School:
Middle School:
William Floyd Middle School
William Floyd Middle School
Middle or Junior School District:
Middle or Junior School District:
William Floyd
William Floyd

Utilities

Cable Available
Electricity Connected
Phone Available
Sewer:
Sewer:
Cesspool
Cesspool
Trash Collection Public
Water Connected
Water Source:
Water Source:
Public
Public

Building and Construction

Architectural Style:
Architectural Style:
Colonial
Colonial
Attic:
Attic:
Pull Stairs
Pull Stairs
Building Area Units:
Building Area Units:
Square Feet
Square Feet
Construction Materials:
Construction Materials:
Frame
Frame
Levels:
Levels:
Two
Two
Property Age:
Property Age:
49
49
Total Square Feet Living:
Total Square Feet Living:
1600
1600
Year Built:
Year Built:
1976
1976

Other Property Info

Annual Tax Amount:
Annual Tax Amount:
10202.00
10202.00
County:
County:
Suffolk County
Suffolk County
Cross Street:
Cross Street:
Floyd Rd.
Floyd Rd.
Directions:
Directions:
LIE To Exit 68 William Floyd Pkwy South, At The Light After The Railroad Tracks Turn Left On Floyd Rd. Make Right Onto Broadway, House Is On Left, #41
LIE To Exit 68 William Floyd Pkwy South, At The Light After The Railroad Tracks Turn Left On Floyd Rd. Make Right Onto Broadway, House Is On Left, #41
Parcel Number:
Parcel Number:
0200-907-00-04-00-007-000
0200-907-00-04-00-007-000
Postal City:
Postal City:
Shirley
Shirley
Postal Code Plus 4:
Postal Code Plus 4:
2503
2503
Property Subtype:
Property Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Single Family Residence
Source Listing Status:
Source Listing Status:
Active
Active
Source Neighborhood:
Source Neighborhood:
Tangier
Tangier
Source Property Type:
Source Property Type:
Residential
Residential
Source System Name:
Source System Name:
C2C
C2C
Subdivision:
Subdivision:
Tangier
Tangier
Tax Year:
Tax Year:
2025
2025

Property Price History

for 41 Broadway

Date	Event	Price	Price/Sqft	Source
Aug 13, 2025	Price Changed	$499,999	$312	OneKeyMLS
Jul 21, 2025	Listed	$549,999	$344	OneKeyMLS
Sep 24, 2001	Sold	$145,000	$140	Public Record
Nov 13, 1995	Sold	$110,000	$106	Public Record

Show more Hide

Property Tax History

for 41 Broadway

Year	Taxes	Land	Additions	Total Assessment
2025	$10,202	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2024	$9,787	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2023	$11,035	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2022	$11,357	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2021	$11,302	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2020	$11,140	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2018	$10,906	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2017	$10,710	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2016	$10,713	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2015	$10,472	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2014	$10,184	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2013	$9,921	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2012	$9,661	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2011	$9,446	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2010	$8,730	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2008	$8,135	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2007	$7,760	$100	$2,350	$2,450
2006	$7,291	$100	$2,350	$2,450

Show more Hide

Sold Homes

near 41 Broadway

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
86 Madison St Mastic, NY 11950SF	$568,000 08/04/2025	1997	3	2	1,590 -10difference	16,117	0.61 mi
86 Madison StSF Mastic, NY 11950 1997 Built 1,590 -10 Sqft 16,117 Lot Size 0.61 mi Distance
6 Bullard St Mastic, NY 11950SF	$385,000 06/24/2025	1970	4	2	1,502 -98	10,890	0.71 mi
6 Bullard StSF Mastic, NY 11950 1970 Built 1,502 -98 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 0.71 mi Distance
45 Heston Rd Shirley, NY 11967SF	$545,000 03/21/2025	1961	4	4	1,500 -100	12,197	0.32 mi
45 Heston RdSF Shirley, NY 11967 1961 Built 1,500 -100 Sqft 12,197 Lot Size 0.32 mi Distance
103 Somerset Ave Mastic, NY 11950SF	$435,000 05/27/2025	1955	4	1	1,500 -100	10,890	0.70 mi
103 Somerset AveSF Mastic, NY 11950 1955 Built 1,500 -100 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 0.70 mi Distance
30 Beacon St Shirley, NY 11967SF	$550,000 05/22/2025	1964	3	2	1,700 +100	9,148	0.96 mi
30 Beacon StSF Shirley, NY 11967 1964 Built 1,700 +100 Sqft 9,148 Lot Size 0.96 mi Distance
21 Stuart Rd Shirley, NY 11967SF	$410,000 03/13/2025	1949	2	1	1,068 -532	11,000	0.06 mi
21 Stuart RdSF Shirley, NY 11967 1949 Built 1,068 -532 Sqft 11,000 Lot Size 0.06 mi Distance
53 Hounslow Rd Shirley, NY 11967SF	$385,000 02/28/2025	1974	7	2	2,033 +433	—	0.09 mi
53 Hounslow RdSF Shirley, NY 11967 1974 Built 2,033 +433 Sqft — Lot Size 0.09 mi Distance
49 Lexington Rd Shirley, NY 11967SF	$470,000 08/11/2025	1972	3	1	1,058 -542	5,227	0.11 mi
49 Lexington RdSF Shirley, NY 11967 1972 Built 1,058 -542 Sqft 5,227 Lot Size 0.11 mi Distance
20 Hounslow Rd Shirley, NY 11967SF	$357,000 05/08/2025	1959	3	2	1,176 -424	10,890	0.14 mi
20 Hounslow RdSF Shirley, NY 11967 1959 Built 1,176 -424 Sqft 10,890 Lot Size 0.14 mi Distance
43 Floyd Rd N Shirley, NY 11967SF	$572,000 07/23/2025	1972	4	3	1,380 -220	23,087	0.19 mi
43 Floyd Rd NSF Shirley, NY 11967 1972 Built 1,380 -220 Sqft 23,087 Lot Size 0.19 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Homes For Sale

near 41 Broadway

Address	Price	Built	Beds	Baths	Sqft	Lot Size	Distance
316 Whittier Dr Mastic Beach, NY 11951SF	$499,900 41 days ago	1994	3	3	1,600	7,500	1.30 mi
316 Whittier DrSF Mastic Beach, NY 11951 1994 Built 1,600 Sqft 7,500 Lot Size 1.30 mi Distance
27 Hampton Ave Mastic, NY 11950SF	$549,000 136 days ago	1973	3	2	1,600	10,019	0.46 mi
27 Hampton AveSF Mastic, NY 11950 1973 Built 1,600 Sqft 10,019 Lot Size 0.46 mi Distance
33 Breston Dr W Shirley, NY 11967SF	$589,000 42 days ago	1972	4	2	1,600	9,148	1.14 mi
33 Breston Dr WSF Shirley, NY 11967 1972 Built 1,600 Sqft 9,148 Lot Size 1.14 mi Distance
52 Arpage Dr E Shirley, NY 11967SF	$495,000 118 days ago	2000	3	3	1,588 -12difference	9,148	1.96 mi
52 Arpage Dr ESF Shirley, NY 11967 2000 Built 1,588 -12 Sqft 9,148 Lot Size 1.96 mi Distance
204 Hawthorne St Mastic, NY 11950SF	$549,000 63 days ago	1999	4	3	1,586 -14	16,117	0.76 mi
204 Hawthorne StSF Mastic, NY 11950 1999 Built 1,586 -14 Sqft 16,117 Lot Size 0.76 mi Distance
27 Dana Ave Mastic, NY 11950SF	$489,000 66 days ago	1915	2	1	1,627 +27	15,682	1.54 mi
27 Dana AveSF Mastic, NY 11950 1915 Built 1,627 +27 Sqft 15,682 Lot Size 1.54 mi Distance
23 Tipton Dr W Shirley, NY 11967SF	$599,999 122 days ago	2023	4	3	1,650 +50	10,019	1.12 mi
23 Tipton Dr WSF Shirley, NY 11967 2023 Built 1,650 +50 Sqft 10,019 Lot Size 1.12 mi Distance
3 Hoover Ct Mastic, NY 11950SF	$599,999 57 days ago	1973	3	3	1,660 +60	7,841	0.80 mi
3 Hoover CtSF Mastic, NY 11950 1973 Built 1,660 +60 Sqft 7,841 Lot Size 0.80 mi Distance
407 Floyd Rd S Shirley, NY 11967SF	$549,000 199 days ago	2025	3	3	1,540 -60	12,197	1.85 mi
407 Floyd Rd SSF Shirley, NY 11967 2025 Built 1,540 -60 Sqft 12,197 Lot Size 1.85 mi Distance
76 Wilson Ave Mastic Beach, NY 11951SF	$449,000 135 days ago	1976	3	1	1,539 -61	10,019	1.56 mi
76 Wilson AveSF Mastic Beach, NY 11951 1976 Built 1,539 -61 Sqft 10,019 Lot Size 1.56 mi Distance

Show more Hide

Schools

serving 41 Broadway

School Name	Rating	Grades	Parent Rating	Distance
William Floyd Elementary School 111 Lexington Road, Shirley, NY 11967	4 / 10	K−5		0.45 mi
K−5 Grades Parent Rating 0.45 mi Distance
William Floyd Learning Center 111 Lexington Road, Shirley, NY 11967	—	K−5	—	0.45 mi
K−5 Grades — Parent Rating 0.45 mi Distance
William Paca Middle School 338 Blanco Drive, Mastic Beach, NY 11951	4 / 10	6−8		1.19 mi
6−8 Grades Parent Rating 1.19 mi Distance
William Floyd High School 240 Mastic Beach Road, Mastic Beach, NY 11951	5 / 10	9−12		1.04 mi
9−12 Grades Parent Rating 1.04 mi Distance
John S Hobart Elementary School 230 Van Buren Street, Shirley, NY 11967	3 / 10	K−5		0.64 mi
K−5 Grades Parent Rating 0.64 mi Distance

Show more Hide

School service boundaries are intended to be used as reference only. To verify enrollment eligibility for a property, contact the school directly.

Flood Factor

for 41 Broadway

1 ^|10

Minimal

FEMA Zone (Est.)

X (unshaded)

Flood insurance:

Recommended

Flood risks are increasing as sea levels rise and weather patterns change.

This property has a Minimal Flood Factor .
Although flood risks across the country are changing because of the environment, this property is unlikely to flood over the next 30 years.

Flood Factor data provided by FloodFactor.

41 Broadway, Shirley, NY 11967

Suffolk County

41 Broadway bool(false) bool(true) bool(true) int(0)

41 Broadway

bool(false) bool(true) bool(true) int(0)